Tool
YES
NO
MAYBE
TIMEOUT
AProVE
213
28
5
22
AProVE 2011
204
28
12
24
Julia
163
22
83
0
COSTA
134
0
117
17
Example
AProVE
AProVE 2011
Julia
COSTA
YES
2.05
YES
2.25
YES
2.73
YES
1.03
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.54
MAYBE
2.56
YES
5.2
YES
4.64
YES
3.22
MAYBE
4.29
YES
15.38
YES
10.18
MAYBE
7.54
TIMEOUT
60
YES
5.23
YES
5.35
MAYBE
5.04
MAYBE
15.93
YES
1.86
YES
2.19
YES
2.38
YES
0.92
YES
3.9
YES
4.36
YES
2.33
YES
1.01
YES
1.68
YES
2.05
YES
2.34
YES
0.9
YES
2.0
YES
18.13
YES
2.54
YES
1.9
YES
1.55
YES
2.13
YES
2.37
YES
0.89
YES
8.68
YES
9.2
YES
5.08
MAYBE
42.1
YES
9.87
YES
14.4
MAYBE
6.02
MAYBE
53.13
YES
9.19
YES
8.13
MAYBE
7.84
TIMEOUT
60
YES
2.38
YES
5.99
MAYBE
2.39
MAYBE
2.75
YES
1.88
YES
3.0
MAYBE
2.34
MAYBE
2.78
YES
2.22
YES
2.98
MAYBE
2.38
MAYBE
2.74
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
2.37
MAYBE
2.64
YES
5.4
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.38
MAYBE
2.92
TIMEOUT
60
YES
12.33
MAYBE
4.21
MAYBE
18.52
YES
2.13
YES
2.36
YES
3.12
YES
1.35
YES
1.84
YES
2.05
YES
2.98
MAYBE
3.53
YES
2.7
YES
6.5
YES
3.14
YES
1.45
YES
2.4
YES
2.6
YES
3.65
MAYBE
19.0
YES
5.09
YES
4.66
MAYBE
2.42
MAYBE
2.61
YES
1.55
YES
1.84
YES
2.51
YES
0.91
YES
3.97
YES
2.4
YES
2.5
MAYBE
2.65
YES
4.88
YES
4.68
MAYBE
2.4
MAYBE
2.62
YES
1.54
YES
1.75
YES
2.56
MAYBE
2.53
YES
2.01
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.32
MAYBE
2.86
YES
1.62
YES
1.81
YES
2.28
YES
0.89
YES
1.78
YES
2.22
YES
2.41
YES
0.92
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.38
MAYBE
2.71
YES
8.0
YES
9.28
MAYBE
4.79
MAYBE
36.24
YES
1.84
YES
2.68
YES
2.61
YES
0.92
YES
2.15
YES
6.88
YES
2.35
YES
0.97
YES
1.72
YES
2.15
YES
2.31
YES
0.91
YES
1.54
YES
1.84
YES
2.2
YES
0.87
YES
1.56
YES
1.8
YES
2.2
YES
0.88
YES
1.7
YES
1.77
YES
2.25
YES
0.92
YES
1.69
YES
1.82
YES
2.33
YES
0.91
YES
1.57
YES
1.81
YES
2.36
YES
0.88
YES
1.7
YES
2.19
YES
2.35
YES
1.72
YES
2.06
YES
2.1
YES
2.36
YES
0.92
YES
2.85
YES
3.32
YES
2.5
YES
0.96
YES
1.77
YES
1.88
YES
2.37
YES
1.01
YES
3.73
YES
9.28
YES
2.45
YES
1.36
YES
2.3
YES
2.33
YES
2.33
YES
0.92
YES
2.47
YES
2.63
YES
2.4
YES
0.95
YES
1.68
YES
1.86
YES
2.27
YES
0.89
YES
2.43
YES
2.86
YES
2.53
YES
0.92
YES
2.08
YES
3.95
YES
2.27
YES
0.94
YES
1.57
YES
1.79
YES
2.15
YES
0.89
YES
1.64
YES
1.82
YES
2.2
YES
0.88
YES
1.56
YES
1.99
YES
2.16
YES
1.64
YES
1.51
YES
1.81
YES
2.2
YES
0.89
YES
1.54
YES
1.57
YES
2.34
YES
0.89
YES
1.53
YES
1.79
YES
2.2
YES
0.89
YES
1.8
YES
1.9
YES
2.28
YES
0.92
YES
1.79
YES
2.35
YES
2.58
YES
1.78
YES
2.46
YES
4.09
YES
2.39
YES
0.95
YES
2.37
YES
3.07
YES
2.35
YES
1.02
YES
1.85
YES
3.29
YES
2.5
YES
1.71
YES
1.69
YES
2.9
YES
2.39
YES
0.93
YES
2.02
YES
3.65
YES
2.39
YES
2.07
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.52
YES
1.8
YES
1.8
YES
2.66
YES
2.43
YES
0.92
YES
2.63
YES
4.26
YES
2.44
YES
1.02
YES
1.63
YES
2.05
YES
2.26
MAYBE
2.7
YES
1.57
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.33
MAYBE
2.52
YES
2.36
YES
1.96
YES
2.95
YES
2.52
YES
13.31
YES
13.62
MAYBE
7.84
MAYBE
17.71
YES
3.13
YES
3.27
YES
3.74
MAYBE
5.08
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
4.08
MAYBE
6.97
YES
1.65
YES
1.89
YES
2.19
YES
0.31
YES
1.68
YES
1.84
YES
2.85
YES
1.53
YES
1.64
YES
2.0
YES
2.59
YES
0.85
YES
1.25
YES
1.16
MAYBE
2.36
MAYBE
3.31
YES
1.75
YES
3.79
YES
2.9
YES
1.26
YES
1.28
YES
1.19
MAYBE
2.71
MAYBE
3.07
YES
1.25
YES
1.16
MAYBE
2.54
MAYBE
3.59
YES
8.98
YES
8.65
YES
4.86
MAYBE
22.03
YES
8.59
YES
11.48
MAYBE
6.62
TIMEOUT
60
YES
1.24
YES
1.15
YES
2.28
MAYBE
2.86
YES
1.25
YES
1.15
YES
2.26
MAYBE
2.51
YES
1.77
YES
1.85
MAYBE
2.44
MAYBE
3.28
YES
2.7
YES
6.67
YES
3.41
YES
1.8
YES
1.24
YES
1.16
YES
2.36
MAYBE
3.17
YES
1.31
YES
1.23
MAYBE
2.98
MAYBE
12.06
YES
1.27
YES
1.17
MAYBE
2.69
MAYBE
3.4
YES
5.65
YES
4.36
MAYBE
2.97
MAYBE
8.05
YES
2.24
YES
9.94
MAYBE
3.39
MAYBE
9.06
YES
1.23
YES
1.17
MAYBE
2.47
MAYBE
1.43
YES
1.3
YES
1.22
MAYBE
2.7
MAYBE
3.01
YES
1.63
YES
1.87
MAYBE
2.73
MAYBE
3.65
YES
2.2
YES
2.25
MAYBE
3.16
MAYBE
4.2
YES
1.27
YES
1.15
MAYBE
2.41
MAYBE
2.6
YES
2.81
YES
3.37
MAYBE
2.96
MAYBE
4.97
YES
7.99
YES
7.51
MAYBE
4.48
MAYBE
12.8
YES
8.46
YES
7.1
MAYBE
4.99
MAYBE
20.39
YES
24.32
YES
5.4
MAYBE
3.01
MAYBE
7.77
YES
12.55
YES
13.57
MAYBE
3.48
MAYBE
9.11
YES
3.2
YES
9.0
MAYBE
6.28
YES
1.61
YES
1.61
YES
1.87
MAYBE
2.63
MAYBE
3.74
YES
2.2
YES
2.22
MAYBE
2.95
MAYBE
5.17
YES
1.28
YES
1.16
MAYBE
2.39
MAYBE
2.61
YES
6.66
YES
12.11
MAYBE
2.79
MAYBE
8.2
YES
2.4
YES
4.71
MAYBE
2.86
MAYBE
5.94
YES
17.94
YES
16.33
MAYBE
4.19
YES
5.88
YES
25.53
YES
33.04
MAYBE
7.14
YES
30.27
YES
8.29
YES
11.41
YES
4.61
YES
3.86
YES
1.9
YES
12.51
YES
2.88
YES
1.48
YES
2.35
YES
6.39
YES
3.22
YES
1.29
YES
1.89
YES
2.69
YES
3.59
MAYBE
3.24
YES
1.83
YES
2.76
YES
2.83
MAYBE
2.68
YES
14.67
YES
6.2
MAYBE
3.29
MAYBE
7.06
YES
1.6
YES
1.86
MAYBE
2.86
MAYBE
4.29
YES
9.48
YES
8.01
MAYBE
3.67
YES
1.5
YES
19.52
MAYBE
18.38
MAYBE
9.07
YES
5.41
YES
4.89
YES
14.08
MAYBE
4.32
YES
3.9
YES
32.12
YES
29.58
YES
3.97
MAYBE
6.35
YES
13.55
MAYBE
6.59
MAYBE
3.91
MAYBE
6.18
TIMEOUT
60
YES
18.06
MAYBE
4.57
MAYBE
9.98
YES
9.17
YES
10.88
MAYBE
3.94
YES
5.2
YES
1.56
YES
1.79
YES
2.46
YES
0.84
YES
1.67
YES
2.31
YES
2.25
YES
0.54
YES
11.88
YES
14.38
MAYBE
5.94
YES
9.65
YES
26.45
MAYBE
12.76
MAYBE
7.19
YES
7.2
YES
4.43
YES
6.55
MAYBE
4.02
MAYBE
7.14
YES
5.97
YES
16.08
MAYBE
3.85
YES
4.8
YES
5.83
YES
14.15
MAYBE
3.02
YES
1.51
YES
2.93
YES
4.08
YES
2.96
MAYBE
4.34
YES
27.06
YES
56.83
MAYBE
4.06
MAYBE
16.01
YES
1.54
YES
1.79
YES
2.36
YES
0.84
YES
4.0
YES
2.42
YES
2.47
MAYBE
2.64
YES
17.76
YES
8.57
MAYBE
3.39
MAYBE
21.19
YES
13.18
YES
7.43
MAYBE
3.45
MAYBE
10.17
YES
11.32
YES
6.08
MAYBE
3.55
MAYBE
7.69
YES
8.01
YES
5.13
MAYBE
3.39
MAYBE
7.35
MAYBE
10.76
YES
12.79
YES
3.94
YES
5.55
YES
10.58
MAYBE
10.55
MAYBE
3.48
TIMEOUT
60
YES
7.84
YES
9.87
MAYBE
3.72
MAYBE
10.33
YES
8.35
YES
17.46
MAYBE
3.6
MAYBE
18.75
YES
1.48
YES
1.6
YES
2.21
YES
0.81
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
19.2
MAYBE
6.76
YES
43.98
YES
12.05
YES
11.61
YES
3.38
TIMEOUT
60
YES
3.06
YES
5.76
YES
2.71
YES
1.39
MAYBE
7.24
MAYBE
8.86
MAYBE
3.11
MAYBE
6.15
YES
2.97
YES
2.21
YES
2.25
YES
1.03
YES
1.4
YES
1.52
YES
2.34
YES
0.28
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.14
MAYBE
0.77
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
2.33
MAYBE
0.67
YES
2.28
YES
3.31
YES
2.81
YES
0.99
YES
1.51
YES
1.67
YES
2.49
YES
1.78
YES
1.2
YES
1.14
YES
2.23
YES
0.25
YES
5.05
YES
5.85
YES
2.82
YES
0.94
YES
1.23
YES
1.15
YES
2.31
YES
0.26
NO
1.24
NO
1.17
NO
2.24
MAYBE
0.63
YES
8.75
YES
8.63
YES
2.87
MAYBE
0.96
YES
1.51
YES
1.81
YES
2.63
MAYBE
0.77
YES
1.23
YES
1.17
YES
2.21
MAYBE
0.76
YES
1.57
YES
1.75
YES
2.78
MAYBE
0.89
NO
1.33
NO
1.22
MAYBE
2.28
MAYBE
0.89
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
3.27
MAYBE
18.2
YES
1.41
YES
1.51
YES
4.58
YES
1.71
NO
1.44
NO
1.31
MAYBE
2.35
MAYBE
0.86
NO
1.54
NO
1.54
MAYBE
2.23
MAYBE
0.72
YES
1.32
YES
1.24
YES
2.27
YES
0.31
NO
1.59
NO
1.54
MAYBE
2.28
MAYBE
0.72
YES
1.31
YES
1.28
YES
2.3
YES
0.31
YES
1.23
YES
1.13
YES
2.37
YES
0.75
MAYBE
6.37
MAYBE
6.31
MAYBE
2.3
MAYBE
2.47
YES
11.11
YES
10.6
YES
17.01
MAYBE
20.82
YES
4.11
YES
8.23
YES
4.4
MAYBE
14.47
YES
1.45
YES
1.59
YES
2.33
YES
0.28
YES
1.42
YES
1.41
YES
2.39
YES
0.29
YES
1.37
YES
1.31
YES
2.27
YES
0.28
YES
1.25
YES
1.16
YES
3.45
YES
1.18
NO
1.53
NO
1.23
MAYBE
2.4
MAYBE
1.48
NO
1.36
NO
1.26
MAYBE
2.31
YES
0.83
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
4.37
MAYBE
2.41
YES
1.2
YES
1.13
YES
2.67
MAYBE
0.79
YES
1.26
YES
1.48
YES
4.4
YES
3.86
YES
1.73
YES
2.33
YES
2.6
YES
1.17
YES
1.49
YES
1.61
YES
3.1
YES
2.1
YES
1.52
YES
1.66
YES
3.73
YES
1.36
YES
7.95
MAYBE
7.89
YES
23.65
TIMEOUT
60
YES
1.4
YES
1.61
YES
2.43
YES
0.27
YES
1.43
YES
1.56
YES
2.37
YES
0.26
YES
2.73
YES
2.09
YES
2.43
YES
0.77
YES
1.24
YES
1.15
YES
2.6
YES
0.26
YES
1.44
YES
1.59
YES
2.72
YES
0.29
YES
1.21
YES
1.14
YES
5.32
YES
0.44
YES
1.35
YES
1.32
YES
2.75
YES
0.64
YES
1.61
YES
1.86
YES
8.56
YES
2.63
YES
1.49
YES
1.4
YES
6.97
YES
3.0
TIMEOUT
60
YES
15.82
YES
4.35
TIMEOUT
60
YES
14.02
YES
21.7
YES
11.1
YES
12.99
YES
7.61
YES
45.6
YES
4.43
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
6.52
MAYBE
2.51
YES
0.4
MAYBE
28.28
MAYBE
7.17
MAYBE
2.85
MAYBE
1.29
YES
1.72
YES
1.74
YES
3.0
YES
1.33
YES
18.75
YES
21.52
YES
4.36
YES
4.02
YES
16.26
YES
20.14
YES
4.1
YES
3.06
YES
25.79
YES
24.46
YES
4.57
YES
6.52
YES
16.89
YES
19.55
YES
4.08
YES
3.15
YES
19.83
YES
21.26
YES
4.33
YES
3.89
YES
3.97
YES
7.1
YES
4.32
MAYBE
6.42
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
57.81
YES
17.09
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
18.88
TIMEOUT
60
YES
13.15
YES
20.65
YES
9.88
YES
14.72
YES
3.85
TIMEOUT
60
YES
7.73
YES
0.73
YES
1.23
YES
1.13
YES
2.6
MAYBE
2.61
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
29.61
TIMEOUT
60
YES
4.32
YES
4.96
YES
3.64
YES
1.01
MAYBE
6.66
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
3.26
MAYBE
2.82
YES
6.23
YES
8.89
YES
6.19
YES
0.49
YES
7.18
YES
17.61
YES
6.65
YES
14.34
YES
3.0
YES
21.97
YES
28.98
TIMEOUT
60
YES
9.73
YES
8.06
YES
4.33
YES
2.81
YES
1.74
YES
4.05
YES
3.78
MAYBE
1.54
YES
9.27
YES
9.48
YES
6.86
MAYBE
14.23
YES
1.9
YES
2.73
YES
3.04
YES
1.82
YES
3.0
YES
4.47
YES
4.31
YES
1.52
YES
3.9
YES
8.23
YES
3.58
YES
2.02
YES
1.95
YES
2.26
YES
3.55
YES
1.19
YES
1.95
YES
2.3
YES
3.56
YES
1.2
YES
1.8
YES
2.04
YES
3.12
YES
1.3
YES
15.53
TIMEOUT
60
YES
21.36
TIMEOUT
60
YES
5.65
TIMEOUT
60
YES
6.84
YES
3.12
YES
7.34
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
13.8
MAYBE
54.25
YES
3.31
YES
3.69
YES
3.75
YES
1.93
YES
2.46
YES
5.53
YES
4.69
YES
0.53
YES
10.38
YES
27.07
YES
15.12
TIMEOUT
60
YES
1.72
YES
2.96
YES
2.73
MAYBE
0.83
YES
5.23
YES
9.63
YES
3.67
YES
1.0
YES
2.0
YES
3.5
YES
9.1
YES
0.4
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
11.29
YES
14.89
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
26.33
TIMEOUT
60
YES
15.4
YES
28.18
YES
4.21
YES
2.41
TIMEOUT
60
MAYBE
8.9
YES
59.02
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
30.66
YES
11.93
YES
18.83
NO
6.34
NO
5.89
NO
2.25
MAYBE
0.64
NO
1.38
NO
1.26
NO
2.23
MAYBE
2.44
NO
1.27
NO
1.16
NO
2.14
MAYBE
0.64
YES
14.57
YES
33.07
YES
52.58
TIMEOUT
60
NO
1.27
NO
1.18
NO
2.28
MAYBE
0.63
NO
1.26
NO
1.22
NO
2.21
MAYBE
0.23
NO
1.3
NO
1.19
NO
2.33
MAYBE
0.26
NO
1.26
NO
1.16
NO
2.09
MAYBE
0.25
NO
1.3
NO
1.21
NO
2.24
MAYBE
0.24
NO
1.39
NO
1.32
NO
2.78
MAYBE
0.28
NO
5.03
NO
5.01
NO
2.18
MAYBE
0.25
NO
1.28
NO
1.19
NO
2.19
MAYBE
0.25
NO
7.46
NO
6.98
NO
2.1
MAYBE
0.24
NO
15.35
NO
14.22
NO
2.18
MAYBE
0.24
NO
13.09
NO
12.26
NO
2.26
MAYBE
0.24
NO
3.33
NO
3.06
NO
2.19
MAYBE
0.24
NO
1.25
NO
1.15
NO
2.16
MAYBE
0.24
NO
1.27
NO
1.18
NO
2.19
MAYBE
0.24
NO
3.19
NO
2.9
NO
2.12
MAYBE
0.24
NO
1.32
NO
1.2
NO
2.08
MAYBE
0.23
NO
1.4
NO
1.3
NO
2.13
MAYBE
0.24
NO
1.29
NO
1.21
NO
2.16
MAYBE
0.67
TIMEOUT
60
TIMEOUT
60
YES
4.74
YES
2.04
YES
4.82
TIMEOUT
60
YES
3.78
YES
0.64
YES
1.88
TIMEOUT
60
YES
3.47
YES
2.11
YES
9.15
YES
8.25
YES
2.85
YES
0.5
YES
3.62
YES
6.18
YES
4.31
YES
2.08