*** 1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: Strict TRS Rules: D(*(x,y)) -> +(*(y,D(x)),*(x,D(y))) D(+(x,y)) -> +(D(x),D(y)) D(-(x,y)) -> -(D(x),D(y)) D(constant()) -> 0() D(div(x,y)) -> -(div(D(x),y),div(*(x,D(y)),pow(y,2()))) D(ln(x)) -> div(D(x),x) D(minus(x)) -> minus(D(x)) D(pow(x,y)) -> +(*(*(y,pow(x,-(y,1()))),D(x)),*(*(pow(x,y),ln(x)),D(y))) D(t()) -> 1() Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: DependencyPairs {dpKind_ = WIDP} Proof: We add the following weak dependency pairs: Strict DPs D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) D#(t()) -> c_9() Weak DPs and mark the set of starting terms. *** 1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) D#(t()) -> c_9() Strict TRS Rules: D(*(x,y)) -> +(*(y,D(x)),*(x,D(y))) D(+(x,y)) -> +(D(x),D(y)) D(-(x,y)) -> -(D(x),D(y)) D(constant()) -> 0() D(div(x,y)) -> -(div(D(x),y),div(*(x,D(y)),pow(y,2()))) D(ln(x)) -> div(D(x),x) D(minus(x)) -> minus(D(x)) D(pow(x,y)) -> +(*(*(y,pow(x,-(y,1()))),D(x)),*(*(pow(x,y),ln(x)),D(y))) D(t()) -> 1() Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: UsableRules Proof: We replace rewrite rules by usable rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) D#(t()) -> c_9() *** 1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) D#(t()) -> c_9() Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: Succeeding Proof: () *** 1.1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) D#(t()) -> c_9() Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: PredecessorEstimation {onSelection = all simple predecessor estimation selector} Proof: We estimate the number of application of {4,9} by application of Pre({4,9}) = {1,2,3,5,6,7,8}. Here rules are labelled as follows: 1: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y ,D#(x) ,x ,D#(y)) 2: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) 3: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) 4: D#(constant()) -> c_4() 5: D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x) ,y ,x ,D#(y) ,y) 6: D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) 7: D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) 8: D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y ,x ,y ,D#(x) ,x ,y ,x ,D#(y)) 9: D#(t()) -> c_9() *** 1.1.1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(constant()) -> c_4() D#(t()) -> c_9() Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: RemoveWeakSuffixes Proof: Consider the dependency graph 1:S:D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_3 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_4 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_3 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 2:S:D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 3:S:D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 4:S:D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) -->_5 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_5 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_5 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_5 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_4 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_3 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_5 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_4 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_3 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_5 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_5 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_5 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_5 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 5:S:D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 6:S:D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 7:S:D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) -->_8 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_7 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_6 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_5 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_4 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_3 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_2 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_1 D#(t()) -> c_9():9 -->_8 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_7 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_6 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_5 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_4 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_3 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_2 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_1 D#(constant()) -> c_4():8 -->_8 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_7 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_6 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_5 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_8 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_7 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_6 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_5 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_8 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_7 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_6 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_5 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_8 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_7 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_6 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_5 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_8 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_7 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_6 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_5 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_8 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_7 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_6 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_5 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_8 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_7 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_6 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_5 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 8:W:D#(constant()) -> c_4() 9:W:D#(t()) -> c_9() The following weak DPs constitute a sub-graph of the DG that is closed under successors. The DPs are removed. 8: D#(constant()) -> c_4() 9: D#(t()) -> c_9() *** 1.1.1.1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: PredecessorEstimationCP {onSelectionCP = any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, withComplexityPair = NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy}} Proof: We first use the processor NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy} to orient following rules strictly: 3: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) The strictly oriented rules are moved into the weak component. *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Just first alternative for predecessorEstimation any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, greedy = NoGreedy} Proof: We apply a matrix interpretation of kind constructor based matrix interpretation: The following argument positions are considered usable: uargs(c_1) = {2,4}, uargs(c_2) = {1,2}, uargs(c_3) = {1,2}, uargs(c_5) = {1,4}, uargs(c_6) = {1}, uargs(c_7) = {1}, uargs(c_8) = {4,8} Following symbols are considered usable: {} TcT has computed the following interpretation: p(*) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(+) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(-) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [1] p(0) = [0] p(1) = [2] p(2) = [8] p(D) = [2] x1 + [2] p(constant) = [4] p(div) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(ln) = [1] x1 + [0] p(minus) = [1] x1 + [0] p(pow) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(t) = [0] p(D#) = [8] x1 + [0] p(c_1) = [1] x2 + [1] x4 + [0] p(c_2) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(c_3) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [7] p(c_4) = [2] p(c_5) = [1] x1 + [1] x4 + [0] p(c_6) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_7) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_8) = [1] x4 + [1] x8 + [0] p(c_9) = [8] Following rules are strictly oriented: D#(-(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [8] > [8] x + [8] y + [7] = c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: D#(*(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) = [8] x + [0] >= [8] x + [0] = c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) = [8] x + [0] >= [8] x + [0] = c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.1.1 Progress [(?,O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: Assumption Proof: () *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: PredecessorEstimationCP {onSelectionCP = any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, withComplexityPair = NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy}} Proof: We first use the processor NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy} to orient following rules strictly: 1: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y ,D#(x) ,x ,D#(y)) The strictly oriented rules are moved into the weak component. *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Just first alternative for predecessorEstimation any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, greedy = NoGreedy} Proof: We apply a matrix interpretation of kind constructor based matrix interpretation: The following argument positions are considered usable: uargs(c_1) = {2,4}, uargs(c_2) = {1,2}, uargs(c_3) = {1,2}, uargs(c_5) = {1,4}, uargs(c_6) = {1}, uargs(c_7) = {1}, uargs(c_8) = {4,8} Following symbols are considered usable: {} TcT has computed the following interpretation: p(*) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(+) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(-) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(0) = [0] p(1) = [0] p(2) = [2] p(D) = [0] p(constant) = [0] p(div) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(ln) = [1] x1 + [0] p(minus) = [1] x1 + [0] p(pow) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(t) = [0] p(D#) = [8] x1 + [0] p(c_1) = [1] x2 + [1] x4 + [15] p(c_2) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(c_3) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(c_4) = [0] p(c_5) = [1] x1 + [1] x4 + [0] p(c_6) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_7) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_8) = [1] x4 + [1] x8 + [0] p(c_9) = [1] Following rules are strictly oriented: D#(*(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [16] > [8] x + [8] y + [15] = c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: D#(+(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) = [8] x + [0] >= [8] x + [0] = c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) = [8] x + [0] >= [8] x + [0] = c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.1.1 Progress [(?,O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: Assumption Proof: () *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: PredecessorEstimationCP {onSelectionCP = any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, withComplexityPair = NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy}} Proof: We first use the processor NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy} to orient following rules strictly: 4: D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) The strictly oriented rules are moved into the weak component. *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Just first alternative for predecessorEstimation any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, greedy = NoGreedy} Proof: We apply a matrix interpretation of kind constructor based matrix interpretation: The following argument positions are considered usable: uargs(c_1) = {2,4}, uargs(c_2) = {1,2}, uargs(c_3) = {1,2}, uargs(c_5) = {1,4}, uargs(c_6) = {1}, uargs(c_7) = {1}, uargs(c_8) = {4,8} Following symbols are considered usable: {} TcT has computed the following interpretation: p(*) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [3] p(+) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(-) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(0) = [4] p(1) = [2] p(2) = [2] p(D) = [2] x1 + [1] p(constant) = [1] p(div) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [1] p(ln) = [1] x1 + [0] p(minus) = [1] x1 + [2] p(pow) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [1] p(t) = [8] p(D#) = [8] x1 + [1] p(c_1) = [1] x2 + [1] x4 + [14] p(c_2) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [15] p(c_3) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [15] p(c_4) = [8] p(c_5) = [1] x1 + [1] x4 + [7] p(c_6) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_7) = [1] x1 + [8] p(c_8) = [1] x4 + [1] x8 + [7] p(c_9) = [1] Following rules are strictly oriented: D#(minus(x)) = [8] x + [17] > [8] x + [9] = c_7(D#(x)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: D#(*(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [25] >= [8] x + [8] y + [16] = c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [17] >= [8] x + [8] y + [17] = c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [17] >= [8] x + [8] y + [17] = c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [9] >= [8] x + [8] y + [9] = c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) = [8] x + [1] >= [8] x + [1] = c_6(D#(x),x) D#(pow(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [9] >= [8] x + [8] y + [9] = c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.1.1 Progress [(?,O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: Assumption Proof: () *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.2 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: PredecessorEstimationCP {onSelectionCP = any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, withComplexityPair = NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy}} Proof: We first use the processor NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Nothing, greedy = NoGreedy} to orient following rules strictly: 1: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) 2: D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x) ,y ,x ,D#(y) ,y) 3: D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) 4: D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y ,x ,y ,D#(x) ,x ,y ,x ,D#(y)) The strictly oriented rules are moved into the weak component. *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.2.1 Progress [(?,O(n^1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: NaturalMI {miDimension = 1, miDegree = 1, miKind = Algebraic, uargs = UArgs, urules = URules, selector = Just first alternative for predecessorEstimation any intersect of rules of CDG leaf and strict-rules, greedy = NoGreedy} Proof: We apply a matrix interpretation of kind constructor based matrix interpretation: The following argument positions are considered usable: uargs(c_1) = {2,4}, uargs(c_2) = {1,2}, uargs(c_3) = {1,2}, uargs(c_5) = {1,4}, uargs(c_6) = {1}, uargs(c_7) = {1}, uargs(c_8) = {4,8} Following symbols are considered usable: {} TcT has computed the following interpretation: p(*) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [3] p(+) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(-) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(0) = [0] p(1) = [1] p(2) = [0] p(D) = [1] x1 + [0] p(constant) = [4] p(div) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(ln) = [1] x1 + [1] p(minus) = [1] x1 + [2] p(pow) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(t) = [1] p(D#) = [8] x1 + [0] p(c_1) = [1] x2 + [1] x4 + [3] p(c_2) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [2] p(c_3) = [1] x1 + [1] x2 + [0] p(c_4) = [1] p(c_5) = [1] x1 + [1] x4 + [1] p(c_6) = [1] x1 + [5] p(c_7) = [1] x1 + [0] p(c_8) = [1] x4 + [1] x8 + [0] p(c_9) = [0] Following rules are strictly oriented: D#(+(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [16] > [8] x + [8] y + [2] = c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [16] > [8] x + [8] y + [1] = c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) = [8] x + [8] > [8] x + [5] = c_6(D#(x),x) D#(pow(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [16] > [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Following rules are (at-least) weakly oriented: D#(*(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [24] >= [8] x + [8] y + [3] = c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) = [8] x + [8] y + [0] >= [8] x + [8] y + [0] = c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(minus(x)) = [8] x + [16] >= [8] x + [0] = c_7(D#(x)) *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.2.1.1 Progress [(?,O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: Assumption Proof: () *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.2.2 Progress [(O(1),O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: RemoveWeakSuffixes Proof: Consider the dependency graph 1:W:D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)) -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 2:W:D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 3:W:D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 4:W:D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y) -->_5 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_5 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_5 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_5 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_5 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_5 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_5 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 5:W:D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 6:W:D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 7:W:D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)) -->_8 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_7 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_6 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_5 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_4 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_3 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_2 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_1 D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y,x,y,D#(x),x,y,x,D#(y)):7 -->_8 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_7 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_6 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_5 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_4 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_3 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_2 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_1 D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)):6 -->_8 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_7 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_6 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_5 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_4 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_3 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_2 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_1 D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x):5 -->_8 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_7 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_6 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_5 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_4 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_3 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_2 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_1 D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x),y,x,D#(y),y):4 -->_8 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_7 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_6 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_5 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_4 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_3 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_2 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_1 D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)):3 -->_8 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_7 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_6 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_5 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_4 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_3 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_2 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_1 D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)):2 -->_8 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_7 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_6 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_5 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_4 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_3 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_2 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 -->_1 D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y,D#(x),x,D#(y)):1 The following weak DPs constitute a sub-graph of the DG that is closed under successors. The DPs are removed. 1: D#(*(x,y)) -> c_1(y ,D#(x) ,x ,D#(y)) 7: D#(pow(x,y)) -> c_8(y ,x ,y ,D#(x) ,x ,y ,x ,D#(y)) 6: D#(minus(x)) -> c_7(D#(x)) 5: D#(ln(x)) -> c_6(D#(x),x) 4: D#(div(x,y)) -> c_5(D#(x) ,y ,x ,D#(y) ,y) 3: D#(-(x,y)) -> c_3(D#(x),D#(y)) 2: D#(+(x,y)) -> c_2(D#(x),D#(y)) *** 1.1.1.1.1.1.2.2.2.2.1 Progress [(O(1),O(1))] *** Considered Problem: Strict DP Rules: Strict TRS Rules: Weak DP Rules: Weak TRS Rules: Signature: {D/1,D#/1} / {*/2,+/2,-/2,0/0,1/0,2/0,constant/0,div/2,ln/1,minus/1,pow/2,t/0,c_1/4,c_2/2,c_3/2,c_4/0,c_5/5,c_6/2,c_7/1,c_8/8,c_9/0} Obligation: Full basic terms: {D#}/{*,+,-,0,1,2,constant,div,ln,minus,pow,t} Applied Processor: EmptyProcessor Proof: The problem is already closed. The intended complexity is O(1).